108
Currently It is not possible to end a production order with RAF = 0 good quantity and 100% scrap for standard cost items. It through "Missing report as finished quantity" error. But this is a possible scenario that when you planned to produce something. Maybe you started operation 10 and that failed and you stopped the order and operation 20 and 30 are not executed and thus you don't have any RAF output on the production order but you have spent time and material ..This is completely a valid scenario in real life.

We have several customers across the globe is requesting for this function. Having this will greatly support customers business. Kindly consider this with high priority.
STATUS DETAILS
Needs Votes
Ideas Administrator

Thank you for your feedback. Currently this is not in our roadmap; however, we are tracking it and if we get more feedback and votes, we may consider it in the future.

Sincerely,

Johan Hoffmann

PM, Microsoft

Comments

V

Is this still not on the roadmap? I get this question from customers every other month...

Category: Production Control

V

This idea proposes to enable ending without a report as finished journal.
I can fully support this idea which is quite generic in as well discrete as process manufacturing industry.
Workaround suggested in the past to register a dummy report as finished, which must be scrapped in inventory does not suit the industry requirement.

By implementing this idea we will:
• reduce unneeded and fictional administrative actions which are probably performed by different roles (SOX impact)
o register report as finished on the order by an operator/planner
o scrap a quantity by the warehouse responsible
o end production order by a financial responsible
• bring the ERP process back in line with business reality, where some productions do not result in an actual yield due to a variety of possible causes:
o nature of the product (e.g. chemical/ biological circumstances) making production results uncertain
o nature of the production (e.g. trial orders)
o cancelling a production order before completion
o …
• provide a more correct and transparent reporting, as well for production efficiency as for scrap reporting.

Category: Production Control

V

Generic requirement for batch AND production orders. This is well needed.

Category: Production Control

V

Agree with others in this thread this is a business necessity and needs this functionality.

Category: Production Control

V

Agreed with others on this thread....the scenario shown simply happens, quite regularly, in a real-life manufacturing environment. This is important to have.

Category: Production Control

V

This is a priority from my point of view. We shouldn't have to vote to get this process in place it's a necessity.

Category: Production Control

V

Absolutely critical for any company that wishes to be SOX compliant. This should not need votes, its barrier for entry to be a serious ERP vendor...

Category: Production Control

V

We have the exact same need. We make clothing at in many cases, something can go wrong in the very last process and we have to scrap the entire order so scrap is reported but no good quantity. We need to show that we spent all this labor and material and did not get any good quantity.

Category: Production Control